How to Make the Picture-Perfect Christmas Cookie Plate (2024)

A cookie plate is such a classic holiday pastime. You might remember your mom making one as a homemade food gift for friends. Or perhaps it was the centerpiece at your grandparents' party every year. Maybe one of your family's Christmas traditions includes making a cookie plate for Santa on December 24. No matter how and when you enjoy it, there's just something so delightful about a pretty platter of sweets!

We know what you're thinking now: You need to create your own cookie plate this Christmas! As our gift to you, we're going to show you how. You might be surprised at how easy, fun, and delicious this baking project can be.

Below are some tips and tricks for assembling a picture-perfect cookie plate. Keep in mind that you can tweak basically any detail to your liking: Change the types of cookies used; package them in a box instead of on a plate. It's totally up to you! This step-by-step is simply a handy guide to get the inspiration flowing. So let's get the cookie party started, and don't forget to tell us how you customize yours in the comments!

How to Build the Perfect Cookie Plate

1. Set your game plan. A great cookie plate should have at least three types of cookies. Or, for the ambitious baker, even more! Plan to include at least 3-5 cookies of each variety, so whoever gets to enjoy your creations can reach back for a second (or third!) of their favorites.
2. Choose some recipes everyone is sure to love. For those who prefer the classics, or for someone you don't know that well, include a few cookies that are “safe” and familiar for all. Hersey Kiss cookies, cut-out sugar cookies, or chocolate crinkle cookies are all winners.
3. But include some of your family’s favorites, too. For the Drummonds, it wouldn’t be the holidays without Ree's favorite Christmas cookies, spicy molasses cookies, or chocolate candy cane cookies. Add a personal touch by baking a few treats that your family holds dear. Who knows—they might become someone else's new go-to!
4. Assemble your cookies. After the planning and baking is done, it's time to put it all together! Start by grouping each batch of cookies together to add some visual organization and keep the plate looking neat. Then, place each group in order around the plate, ending with your favorite, most beautiful cookies in the center.
5. Fill in the gaps with other treats. Candied pecans, chocolate truffles, dried fruits and nuts, and even candy canes can help to fill in the cracks to create an abundant look. Plus, that means they'll have an even broader selection of snacks to choose from. 😏
6. Short on time? Use something store-bought. If you can't commit to three or more homemade recipes, that's okay! You can sub in popular store-bought delights, like biscotti, a Pirouette cookie, or peppermint bark. Paired with a few of your homemade cookies, these easy-to-find options will tastefully round out your plate.

Note: To copy this plate exactly, use spicy molasses cookies, Linzer cookies, Ree's favorite Christmas cookies, peanut butter blossoms, chocolate candy cane cookies, pecan crescents, and spritz cookies. Fill in the gaps with candied pecans and store-bought Pirouette cookies!